• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Shop
  • Pattern Tailor
  • substack
  • Techniques
  • Contact
  • My Account
  • Cart

Jill Wolcott Knits logo

October 22, 2024 2 Comments

An unequal divide between front and back: Overview

Will It Give You Better Fit?

I saw a question about why we don’t do an unequal divide of the bodies of knitted garments. Logically, it would seem to make perfect sense to have an unequal divide, with more fabric in the front because of boobs. But does it?

  • Will It Give You Better Fit?
    • Generally, Why We Don’t Do An Unequal Divide
    • Bodies Are Individual
    • There Are Multitudes of Body Types
    • Averages Are Good, And Not-so-good
    • Why Inclusive Isn’t Necessarily Synonymous With Fit For You
      • Designers
      • Knitters
      • Fit for All
    • Ha, Ha, Now Let’s Look At Unequal Divide

10/24/2024: Edited to fix hourglass hip and trapezoid waist measurements.

tl;dr (reading time approximately 5 minutes–but there are drawings!)

Setting the scene for talking about why we don’t usually unevenly divide garments in knitting, even though it seems kind of logical and necessary.

Generally, Why We Don’t Do An Unequal Divide

Such a good question, and I’m going to try to answer it! First a few clarifications.

  1. The front does not necessarily occupy more space than the back.
  2. Knowing the measurements and body type underlying the design is essential.
  3. Doing an unequal divide will require more time and effort for the designer/pattern writer and is likely not financially viable.
  4. An uneven divide requires some changes to the armhole and sleeve cap.

Let’s make sure we are all looking at bodies and sizing from the same perspective before we dive deeper. I’ve drawn three figures that would potentially wear the same size, based on personal preference and bust measurements.

The three body types I have shown below all have the same bust measurement, but obviously different kinds and amounts of breast tissue. The waist and hip measurements show significant differences for each body type. Let’s assume there is 5″ / 12.7 cm of ease at the bust/chest circumference for a total garment circumference of 44″ / 111.8 cm. That circumference will not actually fit around the hip of the Trapezoid — and in a side view we can’t see the width of the hip.

  • The colored rectangles are a simple garment shape, without any shaping to the upper body.
  • Two arrowed lines on each rectangle represent the even divide of the garment, the garment is aligned to the imaginary side seams.
  • Red dotted vertical lines are the imaginary seams on the body.
  • The horizontal red dotted line would be the underarm of the body.
  • My drawings don’t show any body changes due to aging.

Bodies Are Individual

To accomplish what we know as ready-to-wear (RTW), bodies are standardized and averaged. Knitting patterns are ready-to-wear and meant to fit an “average” body. I will use average throughout this discussion, but that in no way means that “average” equals “ideal”, “correct”, “better”; it just means that from the pool of bodies, these are the averages.

There Are Multitudes of Body Types

For the purposes of RTW the average body type has been hourglass. There is tons of baggage with that choice, which I do not defend, just state as fact. I have several different body types I consider, but it is complicated and becomes even more complicated when trying to attach measurements!

Averages Are Good, And Not-so-good

Averages make things accessible, but not necessarily inclusive! Let’s say you want to design for a busty figure which would need an uneven divide of fabric. Unless you are willing to design for each body individually (couture vs RTW), you have to use averages. By choosing a body type to focus on (a good thing), you are necessarily excluding other body types and, if you are doing RTW, you must use averages. The more general things become, the less fit specific they will be.

Why Inclusive Isn’t Necessarily Synonymous With Fit For You

As designers and companies have sought to be more size inclusive, they have expanded the number of sizes offered, but the sizing is still based on averages, and usually, an hourglass figure type. Without knowing the basic measurements they are starting from, it is hard to know if their sizing is going to fit you. Test knitting offers opportunities to see fit on different body types, but without knowing the person’s measurements and body type, it is not as revelatory as it seems.

Designers

When I or anyone is designing RTW we have no idea what your needs are. Further, I don’t know what your body type is, what your specific measurements are, how you like things to fit, or, even, what yarn you will be using! There is no one answer. No one can make choices that will make it fit everyone. If you are a designer, you can give knitters enough information to make their own fit decisions when using your pattern, but your job is not to provide a couture fit.

Knitters

If you are a knitter, you need to know your measurements, and your own body (or that of the wearer), and your personal preferences. You are choosing the yarn, the size, and ultimately whether or not you make any personal adjustments. You should understand that the designer is designing to averages. You might like to join me and others on the last Wednesday of every month for the Fit Clinic.

Fit for All

Our quest for universality throughout the fashion/clothing/garment and related craft industries gives us fit for none, but has given us low out-of-pocket prices. The result is lots of stuff, but not always the “best” stuff.

Fit has to be a dialogue among all the things: design, preference, measurements, yarn/fabric, bodies, and among all levels of the industry.

Ha, Ha, Now Let’s Look At Unequal Divide

The complexity of this is why I love design and grading. On the other hand, the complexity is the worst part of design and grading!

See the next blog post for more!

Related Posts

  • Happy Dart Solution for Fit When Using A Breast Binder
    Happy Dart Solution for Fit When Using A Breast Binder
  • What is Fit and how does Ease Impact Fit?
    What is Fit and how does Ease Impact Fit?
  • Fabric Influences Fit
    Fabric Influences Fit

Filed Under: Blog, Fit & Design, Sizing Tagged With: average, averages, bodies, body, design, divide, fit, measurements, rtw, type, types, unequal

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Lindsay says

    November 2, 2024 at 8:36 am

    Point 4 was a missing piece for me on the unequal divide – the impact on the underarm and sleeve cap! Thank you, Jill for these broad strokes and helping us all understanding RTW and culture better!!

    Reply
    • Jill says

      November 2, 2024 at 2:54 pm

      I decided to punt on that a bit because that is where it can get so tricky. I do speak a bit about it on the third blog, but I don’t want to throw a lot of stuff out that will scare people off. 🥰

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Jill’s Story

Teacher, Designer, with expertise to lead you where you want to go as a knitter/designer. Read More…

subscribe to my substack

Reference

  • Sizing Chart
  • Pattern Levels

Learn with Jill

  • Why I Love . . . Techniques
  • What Is An Action Chart?
  • Sleeve Length Calculator
  • Seed Stitch Bobbles & Leaves Charts
  • May 2017 Swatch Workshop Secret Page
  • Adding Embellishments Download & Video
  • Secret Plant Fiber Workshop Page
  • Month of Color of the Day by Jill
  • Subscribe to B2B Newsletter
  • Medallion Larger Graphics Download
  • Almost Plaid Yardage & Cast On Calculator
  • LYS Love Sample Patterns Available for Download
  • LYS Love: Sample Pattern Downloads
  • Love LYS Shop Samples Available!
  • Love LYS Sample Pattern Downloads
  • Ashland Large Version Action Charts, Keys, Drawings
  • Belon & Narrow Belon Larger Charts Download
  • Special Offers on New Releases!
  • YNotKnit: Table of Contents
  • J-Squared Knitwear Design Intensive
  • Ormt Worsted Cowl LYS Day Kit
  • Japanese Knitting Stitch Lace-1
  • Introduction Videos, Jill Wolcott Knits
  • Knitwear Design Intensive Schedule
  • Yarnover 2022 Yoke Sweater Construction for Real Bodies Homework
  • Naples Test Knit
  • Naples Test Knit in 6 Variations
  • What You Want to Know: J-Squared Design Intensive
  • Knitter’s Math Answer (s) for Giveaway
  • Memphis Rib Trim PU Calculator (3 types of rib)
  • Phoenix is Rise Up Collection Design 7
  • Cart
  • Designer’s Story
  • About Jill Wolcott & Jill Wolcott Knits
  • Shop
  • Fundraising Projects
  • Contact
  • Abbreviations
  • Privacy Policy
  • Techniques Library : How to Find a Technique
  • Sizing Tables / Charts / Guidelines & Croquis
  • Inside a Jill Wolcott Knits Pattern
  • Patterns
  • Knit.Design.Edit.Sleep.Repeat.
  • Sizing [R]Evolution
  • ASOG 2022 (A System of Grading) Kicks Off
  • A Perfect Dress
  • Using a Bust Dart Calculator
  • Style Formatting and How to Read Text
  • Buttons Links Are a Practical Closure with Panache, Perfect for Knits
  • Horizontal Bust Dart Pullover Pullover: User Guide
  • User Guide: Lyon Traboules Questions
  • The Fabulous Pattern Tailor
  • Description for Horizontal Bust Dart Calculator
  • How the Pattern Tailor Works
  • User Guide: Path to Maiori Questions
  • PATTERN TAILOR: Release Trio Visuals
  • Lyon Traboules User Guide
  • Looking for Measurement Fillable Forms?
  • Peete, the Pattern Tailor:
  • Berkshires Cowl: Power Tools You Need to Make a Fantastic Cowl
  • Photos of Berkshires Cowl in Malabrigo
  • Videos for Using the Pattern Tailor
  • User Guide for Berkshires Cowl
  • FLTCO User Guide (Flexible Long-tail Cast On)
  • User Guide for LTCO (Long-Tail Cast On) Calculator
  • YRF User Guide (Yarn Remainder Finder)
  • Calculators: Output Sheets & User Guides
  • Time to Knit User Guide (T2K)
  • Measuring Worksheet
  • A potpourri of knitting techniques
  • Porto Pre-Pattern Documents
  • Napoli Pre-Pattern Documents
  • BO Calculator User Guide
  • JSSBO Calculator User Guide
  • Knitters’ Math: KM Documents
  • Arno Shawl
  • Langley Photos
  • Proportion & Volume
  • Selfish Knitting
  • User Guide for Attached & Apart: Chios Cowl
  • Join Me for A Fit Trip; Everything to Know About Route 66
  • Ease Article: 4/9/2026 Downloads
  • What You Need To Know About Gauge
  • Fit Goals: What Does “garments that fit” mean?
  • Welcome to the Pattern Tailor
  • Pattern Tailor: Bust Dart Calculators
  • Pattern Tailor: Designer Tools
  • Pattern Tailor: Jill Wolcott Knits Designs
  • Pattern Tailor: Tools

Join Jill on Craftsy

Join Jill on Craftsy

Join Jill on Craftsy. Create Beautiful, New Patterns from the Basics You Know!

Blog Archives

Follow Jill Wolcott Knits

Footer

About Jill

Teacher, Designer, with expertise to lead you where you want to go as a knitter/designer.

Newsletter: Inside Scoop!

Subscribe

Pattern Availability

If you live outside of the US and Canada you can now purchase Jill Wolcott Knits PDF patterns directly through Payhip.

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Ravelry

© 2026 Jill Wolcott Knits