• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Shop
  • Pattern Tailor
  • substack
  • Techniques
  • Contact
  • My Account
  • Cart

Jill Wolcott Knits logo

January 12, 2016 Leave a Comment

Charts Match Written

Charts Match Written: Obstacles in Knitting

I’ve written lots of words on the Obstacles in Knitting road to get to Charts Match Written! All the things I’ve written about were on the initial list of notes I made when I decided to do this, but I think charts match written was the trigger.

Charts Match Written: Overview

The stitch pattern dictionaries that Barbara G. Walker first produced did not have charts. There are now four volumes, originally three actual dictionaries: A Treasury of Knitting Patterns (1968) , A Second Treasury of Knitting Patterns (1970), Charted Knitting Designs: A Third Treasury of Knitting Patterns (1972). These were originally published by Charles Scribner’s Sons, are now published by Schoolhouse Press. There are other resources, but these were kind of the gold standard. They are the first place I go when looking for a particular type of pattern because of how they are indexed, organized, photographed, and especially for Ms. Walker’s pithy comments that accompany many of the patterns.

So, don’t get me wrong. These are a fabulous resource. But I have a bone to pick with how Ms. Walker deals with extra stitches in written stitch patterns–not because they are wrong, but because they have bred bad habits in those who use the stitch patterns. No other resource does it differently, so I use Ms. Walker’s work as an example, from the best.

When there are no extra stitches, the pattern is written like this:

Row 1: *K1, p1; rep from *

Row 2: *P1, k1; rep from *

When there are extra stitches in a stitch pattern, they might appear at either or both ends of the repeat. the pattern might appear like this:

Example A:

Multiple of 4 sts + 2

Row 1: K2, *p2, k2; rep from *

Row 2: P2, *k2, p2; rep from *

Example B:

Multiple of 8 sts + 6

Row 1: K6, *p2, k6 rep from *

Row 2: K1, *p4, k4; rep from *, end p4, k1

My problem is that if I put markers in on Row 1, to separate the extra stitches from the repeat, when I work Row 2, the extra stitches are not in the same place, and hence my markers aren’t helping me at all. Let’s look at the examples.

Example A: Row 1 starts with 2 extra stitches at the beginning, so I would put a marker after the first K2. Then, on Row 2, the extra stitches are at the beginning as well–but my marker is at the beginning of the first row. Since this is a simple stitch pattern, one could easily move forward, but the written now doesn’t match the marker.

Example B: Row 1 has the extra 6 stitches at the beginning, and none at the end of the first row, so the marker goes in after those initial 6 stitches. Row 2 has 1 extra stitch at the beginning, and 5 extra stitches at the end. Again, this doesn’t match my marker from Row 1.

So this puts my brain into a knot. In the particular pattern I used for Example B, there are 10 rows. None of the RS rows match the WS rows.

Charts=written: Obstacles in Knitting, original

The orange box shows how the stitch repeat lines up as you move from row to row. Note: the chart to the left is an action chart. It is the same orange box if you use an appearance chart (I made this one in StitchMaps.com.)

Charts=written: Obstacles in Knitting, original appearance

Charts Match Written: Consistency in Repeat

The charts above shows there really isn’t a row to row repeat. But in a grid, it is easy to see how the row-to-row repeat can be rewritten to make it easy to work within markers.  Here’s a chart, with an equal number of extra stitches on either side of the repeat.

Charts=Written: Obstacles in Knitting

Even if you don’t want to work from a chart, the pattern can now easily be rewritten so that if you put in markers so there are 3 stitches on either side of the repeat(s), the extra stitches are the same every row. The orange box can be moved anywhere horizontally and this will still be the case. Note: the chart to the left is an action chart.

Example B:

Row 1: K3, *k3, p2, k3; rep from *, end k3

Row 2: K1, p2, *p2, k4, p2; rep from *, end p2, k1Charts=written: Obstacles in Knitting, original appearance

See how much better that is when charts match written! If you prefer an appearance chart, here’s one I created using StitchMaps.com. Even if you aren’t providing charts, I believe that having the repeats line up provides the opportunity for the knitter to use markers in a meaningful way. I do not see why the other way is preferable; saving a little written space should not be the driving factor in providing useful and useable stitch patterns to knitters.

Filed Under: Blog, Obstacles, Obstacles in Knitting Tagged With: charts, charts=written, dictionaries, extra stitches, pattern dictionaries, Schoolhouse Press, stitch dictionaries, stitch pattern, stitch patterns, Treasury of Knitting, written

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Jill’s Story

Teacher, Designer, with expertise to lead you where you want to go as a knitter/designer. Read More…

subscribe to my substack

Reference

  • Sizing Chart
  • Pattern Levels

Learn with Jill

  • Why I Love . . . Techniques
  • What Is An Action Chart?
  • Sleeve Length Calculator
  • Seed Stitch Bobbles & Leaves Charts
  • May 2017 Swatch Workshop Secret Page
  • Adding Embellishments Download & Video
  • Secret Plant Fiber Workshop Page
  • Month of Color of the Day by Jill
  • Subscribe to B2B Newsletter
  • Medallion Larger Graphics Download
  • Almost Plaid Yardage & Cast On Calculator
  • LYS Love Sample Patterns Available for Download
  • LYS Love: Sample Pattern Downloads
  • Love LYS Shop Samples Available!
  • Love LYS Sample Pattern Downloads
  • Ashland Large Version Action Charts, Keys, Drawings
  • Belon & Narrow Belon Larger Charts Download
  • Special Offers on New Releases!
  • YNotKnit: Table of Contents
  • J-Squared Knitwear Design Intensive
  • Ormt Worsted Cowl LYS Day Kit
  • Japanese Knitting Stitch Lace-1
  • Introduction Videos, Jill Wolcott Knits
  • Knitwear Design Intensive Schedule
  • Yarnover 2022 Yoke Sweater Construction for Real Bodies Homework
  • Naples Test Knit
  • Naples Test Knit in 6 Variations
  • What You Want to Know: J-Squared Design Intensive
  • Knitter’s Math Answer (s) for Giveaway
  • Memphis Rib Trim PU Calculator (3 types of rib)
  • Phoenix is Rise Up Collection Design 7
  • Cart
  • Designer’s Story
  • About Jill Wolcott & Jill Wolcott Knits
  • Shop
  • Fundraising Projects
  • Contact
  • Abbreviations
  • Privacy Policy
  • Techniques Library : How to Find a Technique
  • Sizing Tables / Charts / Guidelines & Croquis
  • Inside a Jill Wolcott Knits Pattern
  • Patterns
  • Knit.Design.Edit.Sleep.Repeat.
  • Sizing [R]Evolution
  • ASOG 2022 (A System of Grading) Kicks Off
  • A Perfect Dress
  • Using a Bust Dart Calculator
  • Style Formatting and How to Read Text
  • Buttons Links Are a Practical Closure with Panache, Perfect for Knits
  • Horizontal Bust Dart Pullover Pullover: User Guide
  • User Guide: Lyon Traboules Questions
  • The Fabulous Pattern Tailor
  • Description for Horizontal Bust Dart Calculator
  • How the Pattern Tailor Works
  • User Guide: Path to Maiori Questions
  • PATTERN TAILOR: Release Trio Visuals
  • Lyon Traboules User Guide
  • Looking for Measurement Fillable Forms?
  • Peete, the Pattern Tailor:
  • Berkshires Cowl: Power Tools You Need to Make a Fantastic Cowl
  • Photos of Berkshires Cowl in Malabrigo
  • Videos for Using the Pattern Tailor
  • User Guide for Berkshires Cowl
  • FLTCO User Guide (Flexible Long-tail Cast On)
  • User Guide for LTCO (Long-Tail Cast On) Calculator
  • YRF User Guide (Yarn Remainder Finder)
  • Calculators: Output Sheets & User Guides
  • Time to Knit User Guide (T2K)
  • Measuring Worksheet
  • A potpourri of knitting techniques
  • Porto Pre-Pattern Documents
  • Napoli Pre-Pattern Documents
  • BO Calculator User Guide
  • JSSBO Calculator User Guide
  • Knitters’ Math: KM Documents
  • Arno Shawl
  • Langley Photos
  • Proportion & Volume
  • Selfish Knitting
  • User Guide for Attached & Apart: Chios Cowl
  • Join Me for A Fit Trip; Everything to Know About Route 66
  • Ease Article: 4/9/2026 Downloads
  • What You Need To Know About Gauge
  • Fit Goals: What Does “garments that fit” mean?
  • Welcome to the Pattern Tailor
  • Pattern Tailor: Bust Dart Calculators
  • Pattern Tailor: Designer Tools
  • Pattern Tailor: Jill Wolcott Knits Designs
  • Pattern Tailor: Tools

Join Jill on Craftsy

Join Jill on Craftsy

Join Jill on Craftsy. Create Beautiful, New Patterns from the Basics You Know!

Blog Archives

Follow Jill Wolcott Knits

Footer

About Jill

Teacher, Designer, with expertise to lead you where you want to go as a knitter/designer.

Newsletter: Inside Scoop!

Subscribe

Pattern Availability

If you live outside of the US and Canada you can now purchase Jill Wolcott Knits PDF patterns directly through Payhip.

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Ravelry

© 2026 Jill Wolcott Knits